Creamy, tangy, and just the right amount of sweet, Thousand Island Dressing is the ultimate multi-purpose condiment. Whether you’re layering it on a classic Reuben sandwich, using it as a dip for crisp veggies, or tossing it into a fresh salad, this dressing brings a nostalgic, comforting flavor that’s hard to beat.

Homemade Thousand Island Dressing has a freshness that bottled versions simply can’t replicate. With a base of mayo and ketchup, plus just a touch of acidity and spice, you get a thick, luscious dressing with flavor depth and balance. You’ll wonder why you ever bought it pre-made.

Preparation Phase & Tools to Use

Before you dive into mixing, a few basic tools will make the prep smoother:

Mixing Bowl: A medium-sized mixing bowl gives you enough room to whisk ingredients without spilling.
Whisk or Fork: For proper blending and that creamy texture, a whisk helps emulsify the components together.
Measuring Spoons & Cups: Precision matters! Too much ketchup or vinegar can throw off the whole balance.

Glass Jar or Airtight Container: Perfect for storing the dressing in the fridge. A clear glass jar also makes it easy to see how much you have left.

Having these tools at hand not only saves time but ensures your Thousand Island Dressing comes out smooth and well-balanced every time.

Ingredients for the Thousand Island Dressing

Each ingredient in this recipe plays a key role in building the bold and creamy flavor you expect from Thousand Island Dressing:

Mayonnaise: The creamy, rich base that gives the dressing its signature texture.
Ketchup: Adds a tangy sweetness and that familiar pink-orange hue.
Sweet Pickle Relish: Delivers little pops of sweetness and crunch that brighten the dressing.

White Vinegar: Cuts through the richness with a subtle tang, balancing the overall flavor.
Granulated Sugar: Just a touch to round out the acidity and enhance the sweetness.
Finely Minced Onion: Brings a fresh, zesty kick that adds complexity.

Garlic Powder: A gentle, savory backdrop that enhances all the other flavors.
Salt and Pepper: Essential for balance, they bring out the best in every ingredient.

How To Make the Thousand Island Dressing

Step 1: Combine the Base

In your mixing bowl, add the mayonnaise and ketchup. Whisk together until fully blended into a smooth and creamy mixture.

Step 2: Add Texture and Tang

Mix in the sweet pickle relish, vinegar, and sugar. Stir until evenly combined, allowing the sugar to dissolve completely.

Step 3: Layer the Flavor

Add in the finely minced onion and garlic powder. Stir thoroughly to ensure everything is evenly distributed.

Step 4: Season and Adjust

Sprinkle in salt and freshly ground pepper to taste. Give the dressing a final whisk and taste—adjust seasoning if needed.

Step 5: Chill Before Serving

Transfer the finished dressing to your glass jar or airtight container. Refrigerate for at least 1 hour before using. This rest time lets the flavors meld beautifully.

How to Serve and Store Thousand Island Dressing

This creamy dressing isn’t just for salads—it shines in a variety of dishes. Spoon it generously onto burgers or use it as a spread in your favorite sandwich (especially Reubens). It’s also fantastic as a dip for fries, chicken tenders, or veggie sticks.

To store, place the dressing in a glass jar or any airtight container. Keep it refrigerated, and it will stay fresh for up to 7 days. Just give it a good stir before each use to refresh the texture.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Thousand Island Dressing different from Russian Dressing?

While both have a mayo-ketchup base, Russian dressing is typically spicier and includes horseradish or chili sauce. Thousand Island leans sweeter and includes relish.

Can I make this dressing dairy-free?

Yes! Just make sure to use a dairy-free mayo. The rest of the ingredients are already dairy-free.

Is it possible to use fresh pickles instead of relish?

Absolutely. Finely chop sweet pickles and use them in place of relish. You may want to add a touch more sugar to balance the flavor.

How long does homemade Thousand Island Dressing last?

Stored properly in the fridge, it stays fresh for up to a week. Always use a clean spoon to avoid contamination.

Can I freeze this dressing?

It’s not recommended. Mayo-based dressings don’t freeze well and can separate when thawed.

What if I don’t have white vinegar?

You can substitute with apple cider vinegar or lemon juice, but note that it may slightly alter the flavor.

Want More Dressing & Dip Ideas?

If you’re loving this Thousand Island Dressing, you’ll definitely want to try these other flavor-packed recipes:

• Creamy Garlic Butter Lobster Tails – perfect for seafood nights.
• Creamy Spicy Buffalo Ranch Pasta – brings heat and creaminess together.
• Mediterranean Feta Dipping Oil – light, herby, and great for bread or salads.
• Creamy Garlic Butter Chicken Rotini – rich and satisfying.
• Creamy Honey Buffalo Steak Pasta Bake – a full-flavor meal for cozy nights.

And if you’re looking for more recipes like this one, check out my daily recipe collection over on Pinterest: Life With Olivia on Pinterest

Save This Recipe for Later

📌 Save this recipe to your Pinterest board so it’s always just a click away when you need it.

Let me know in the comments how you served your Thousand Island Dressing! Did you stick to the classic salad or go creative with burgers or wraps?

I love seeing the unique twists you all bring to these recipes. Don’t be shy—drop your questions or flavor ideas below. We’re in this kitchen adventure together.

Thousand Island Dressing

Author: Olivia McKenney
Total Time: 10 minutes + 1 hour chill
Yield: About 1¼ cups

Diet: Vegetarian

Print Recipe

Description

Creamy, tangy, and slightly sweet, this homemade Thousand Island Dressing is a versatile condiment perfect for salads, sandwiches, burgers, and dipping. With just a few pantry staples, you can whip up a fresher, more flavorful version than anything store-bought.

Ingredients

1 cup mayonnaise

1/4 cup ketchup

2 tablespoons sweet pickle relish

2 teaspoons white vinegar

2 teaspoons granulated sugar

1 tablespoon finely minced onion

1/4 teaspoon garlic powder

1/8 teaspoon salt

1/8 teaspoon black pepper

Instructions

1. In a medium mixing bowl, combine the mayonnaise and ketchup. Whisk until smooth and fully blended.

2. Stir in the sweet pickle relish, white vinegar, and granulated sugar. Mix until the sugar is dissolved.

3. Add the minced onion and garlic powder, stirring until well incorporated.

4. Season with salt and black pepper. Whisk again and taste to adjust seasoning if needed.

5. Transfer the dressing into a glass jar or airtight container. Chill in the refrigerator for at least 1 hour before serving to allow the flavors to meld.